How to Recruit CIOs More Successfully

Written by Bjorn Ovar Johansson

In the current complex and fast-moving digital world, it is often challenging to recruit CIOs. Having an experienced interim CIO onboard supporting the process of hiring a permanent CIO can significantly reduce the risk during (the interim CIO is steading and controlling the ship) and after. Considering the value-add, avoiding a CIO ‘gap’, and minimising the risk for hiring a, on paper, ‘great’, CIO who then leaves pre-maturely, could make this concept an investment worth considering. The purpose of this article is to elaborate on this approach.

BACKGROUND

With 25 years in CIO and IT leadership positions (12 as an independent interim including one year for an international recruitment business) the following ideas will hopefully provide sensible (and some provocative?) advice to recruiters and CPOs on how to hire CIOs more successfully.

As IT and digital has become increasingly complex and business critical over the last decade, it has also become harder to effectively recruit great CIOs (at least compared with 10 years ago and compared with most other CXO roles). 

The complexity lays in identifying candidates with the right skill set, mindset and cultural fit for the role, whilst also providing them with a precise role description and an accurate picture of current and desired future state of digital technology in the hiring organisation. This at a time when ‘digital’ is exploding in presenting new business opportunities and risks. 

There is little hard data proving the employment time for CIO has declined vs CXO peers. However, there are indications that CIO tenures are shorter than before. To what extent this is due to challenges in accurately depicting what the incoming CIO need to deliver and with what skillset, can be discussed. Regardless, we are good at recruiting GREAT PEOPLE, however, not always at hiring the RIGHT individual for a specific set of (partly unknown) challenges. Let’s have a brief look at history before we come back to why, what, and how to improve.

THE CIO ROLE HAS CHANGED DRAMATICALLY IN THE LAST DECADE!

10-20 years ago, IT was primarily about ‘keeping the lights on’, manging inhouse servers, physical networks, a handful of applications and supporting PC and laptop users. The biggest fright was the ‘Millennium bug’ whilst security meant ‘patching’ and system upgrades. Most business processes had little or no system support (accounts payable as one example).

17 of the top 30 innovations of the last 30 years are IT related including internet, laptops, smart phones, and email. These, together with robotics and the financial industry (e.g., credit cards) are regarded top 35 inventions of all time.

Digital now revolutionise how we run our businesses. Seamless global supply chains, remote work, factory automation, e-commerce and social media are a given today. Technologies such as cloud, IoT, automation, machine learning, augmented reality (metaverse) and connectivity enable (and push) businesses to reinvent how they operate and open for new, challenger businesses to redefine operating models, creating new services, products, and even markets.

Among the top 10 Fortune 100 businesses, there was a shift from energy and automotive in 2013 to digital companies with Walmart, Amazon, Apple and Alphabet, and health companies such as CVS Health and McKesson, all in top 10 in 2023.

Amazon, Netflix, and Uber are examples that it often takes 10 years until a new technology is fully commercialised. Cloud and e-commerce are still to be fully exploited. Generative AI seem to be moving at speed and ‘sustainable IT’ will soon be a key part of ESG.

WHAT DOES THIS MEAN FROM A RECRUITING PERSPECTIVE?

The CIO role has moved from ‘business as usual’, managing a technology team, hardware, and an application landscape to a multi-faceted, complex, and acritical position from a business development perspective. This fast-paced environment, with new competition that challenge business models and creates new market leaders, makes the CIO role even more fundamental.

New factors come into play, which makes the CIO recruitment process more challenging! We need to precisely express what the CIO must master, and we must understand the current state of the IT department, the digital vision and strategy, and the implementation roadmap for IT!

Furthermore, key words for a role description might include communication skills, business awareness, customer centricity, transformational and organisational change management, information and cyber security, digital expertise, agile development, building a winning team, governance, performance management and a range of acronyms such as GDPR, DevOps, IoT, LLM, AI, Gen AI and GPT4 (some of which we are perhaps only vaguely familiar with).

Finally, we want to find candidates with significant sector experience, people who fit in our business culture and who would prosper, thrive, and deliver value over a foreseeable future.

Is it possible for a hiring manager, CPO, and recruiter to, in a few weeks, create an accurate brief and a job description covering all above? Hopefully, but it is not an easy task…

HOW TO IMPROVE THE SUCCESS RATE?

Can we better safeguard that new CIOs understands what they signed up for and what is required to succeed, thrive, and deliver business value for the next several years? Definitely!

Without having spent significant time on the inside (rarely the case) candidates only rely on own due diligence, interviews and materials provided such as the role description. One could argue that the actual situation and challenges, when taking up a new CIO role, might look very different compared with what was perceived whilst in the recruitment process. 

In some cases, this leads to disappointment; for the candidate, if the assignment and role turn out differently than rightly anticipated, and the hiring organisation and recruiter may not feel the new CIO was such a good match after. Worst case, a failed recruitment is a very expensive outcome for all parties and sets us back to square one. However, this risk can be managed!

ENGAGE AN INTERIM CIO TO PAVE THE WAY FOR SUCCESS…

A slightly different approach to traditional permanent recruitment is ‘Hire and Buy’, meaning bringing in a seasoned interim CIO as a first step in the process.

An experienced interim CIO has done these types of assignments many times, has held several CIO positions in multiple sectors and can offer value-add already in the first week and is often available to start almost immediately.

The interim CIO can lead and manage the IT organisation, deliver urgent changes, including quick wins and other improvements, whilst at the defining and documenting exactly what needs to be done going forward including outlining or updating the IT vision, strategy, and roadmap, describing the existing corporate and business technology culture and what precise qualities and skills are required in the incoming, permanent CIO.

As soon as the more precise brief, role description and roadmap are agreed, the interim CIO can participate in the hiring process, ensuring a good match between the company needs and mission, and the permanent CIO’s driving forces and competences.

Once the incoming CIO is available, the interim CIO can introduce the successor, handing over and ensuring a smooth onboarding during a period of a few weeks, allowing the incoming CIO to focus on meeting senior stakeholders, getting to know the team and the business (without having to deal with IT incidents or any other operational matters).  

Exhibit: The two strategies from a time perspective

An investment in an interim CIO can be viewed in terms of business value added, avoiding a leadership vacancy and optimising the chance that the incoming CIO is not only a great hire, but a great hire for a very specific set of circumstances and a unique position.


ABOUT THE AUTHOR

Bjorn Ovar Johansson is the Founder of Senior IT Executive Limited. He is active as interim CIO and advisor in EMEA, the US and APAC. Based in Manchester, he specialises in IT organisational turn-arounds and digital business transformations.

Do not hesitate to make contact for questions, advise or if you would like to provide your organisation with a presentation on this topic.

M: +447884838102      E: ovar@telia.com